All of the large animal charities are partnering with industry to promote happy exploitation.
All of the large animal charities and their supporters reject abolition as it is presented here:
* a rejection of the status of animals as property and recognition of nonhuman personhood based only on sentience;
* an emphasis on veganism as a moral imperative;
* a rejection of welfare campaigns, which merely increase production efficiency, and single-issue campaigns, which normalize animal exploitation by reinforcing the idea that the problem is the “abuse” being targeted and not our eating, wearing, and using animals and are often used to promote discrimination against humans; and
* a recognition that human rights and animal rights are inextricably intertwined and that sexism, racism, heterosexism, or violence have no place in the animal rights movement.
All of the large animal charities and their supporters simultaneously claim to be “abolitionists” who support welfare regulation, happy exploitation, single-issue campaigns, and reject the human rights/animal rights connection.
(Click to enlarge image.)
The level of confusion is profound.
To those who claim that no one has a monopoly on “abolition” and they can describe themselves as “abolitionists” even they support welfare reform, happy exploitation, and single-issue campaigns, I would reply that no one has a monopoly on “apple” either. You can choose to call a banana an apple if you want. But that does not mean that a banana is an apple.
**********
If animals matter morally at all–if animals are not mere things that exist as resources for human use–than veganism is the only rationally response.
If you are not vegan, please go vegan. Going vegan is easy, better for your health and the heath of the planet, and most important, it is what we owe morally to nonhuman animals.
The World is Vegan! If you want it.
Gary L. Francione
Board of Governors Distinguished Professor, Rutgers University
©2014 Gary L. Francione
The post The Animal Confusion Movement appeared first on Animal Rights: The Abolitionist Approach.
Related posts:
Animal Rights: Marginalized By The “Animal Movement”
Got Faith (in Animal Welfare)?
Veganism: The Fundamental Principle of the Abolitionist Movement
The State of the Movement
BBC World Service to Do 2-Part Program on Animals and Animal Movement